Elks Lodge is a association or organization in Newcomerstown, OH. Phone: (740) 498-6232. Average rating is 4.7 stars from 35 reviews.
Benevolent and Protective Order of Elks emblemNewcomerstown, OH Elks Lodge #1555
Call Now Directions
Review
A young dancer performing in a polka dot costume. — Elks Lodge
4.7 35 reviews

Brotherhood, Cold Drinks, and a Real Welcome

Newcomerstown's Elks Lodge on West Main delivers genuine community, great food, and a bar worth coming back to.

Charity

Giving without expectation

Justice

Fairness for every person

Brotherly Love

Fellowship above all

Fidelity

Faithful to our word

About Us

Four girls in colorful outfits posing for a photo. — Elks Lodge
Four girls in colorful outfits posing for a photo.

Walk through the door at 118 W Main St and you'll feel it immediately: this is a place where strangers become regulars on the first visit. Reviewers say it plainly, that the officers put guests first and the welcome is genuine, not performative. The pool table gets plenty of action, the bar is well-stocked, and the crowd is the kind you actually want to spend an evening with.

The Benevolent and Protective Order of Elks has served American communities since 1868, and the Newcomerstown lodge carries that tradition forward with a distinctly Ohio small-town personality. Birthday celebrations, casual Friday nights, and post-meeting dinners all find a natural home here. The food earns its own praise, drawing locals who come back specifically for the kitchen.

With a 4.7-star rating across 35 reviews, this lodge isn't coasting on history alone. It earns its reputation one plate, one conversation, and one game of pool at a time.

What We Offer

The lodge delivers a full social experience under one roof. The bar program is the anchor, offering a well-curated selection that keeps members and guests returning well after the first round. Pull up a stool, challenge someone to a game on the pool table, or settle into a booth and catch up with neighbors.

Food service is a genuine draw, not an afterthought. The kitchen has hosted birthday parties, family gatherings, and casual weeknight dinners with equal care. Members enjoy access to Elks Lodge events throughout the year, including charitable fundraisers, community programs, and lodge-organized socials that connect Newcomerstown residents in meaningful ways.

Non-members are welcomed as guests, making this a great first stop before exploring membership in one of America's oldest fraternal organizations.

What Our Guests Say

Don't just take our word for it - hear it from our members & guests

Click to Rate & Review This Business ✍️
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
7 years ago
"I was treated like a regular when I walked in. The club has a pool table and a fantastic bar. The officers were friendly and they put their guests first."
— Dave Johnson
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
2 years ago
"Very nice club..great food ..met some like locals...can't wait to go back."
— Debbie Holbrook
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
4 years ago
"Great food. Good service & a wonderful time for my daughter Sandy's birthday celebration."
— Mary Spinks
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
2 years ago
"One of the best choices I made was to become a member of Newcomerstown Elks in my home town! Their food is so slap! 😋😋😋😋😋❤❤❤❤❤❤"
— Capri Newman
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
4 years ago
"Cheap drinks, good people and clean bathrooms. TOTALLY worth the yearly price to be a member."
— Alexandra Martin

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I have to be a member to visit the Newcomerstown Elks Lodge?

Non-members are welcome as guests of current members. If you're curious about membership, the officers are happy to walk you through the process during your visit.

Does the lodge serve food?

Yes, the kitchen is a real highlight. Reviewers specifically praise the food quality, and the lodge has hosted birthday parties and family gatherings in addition to everyday dining.

What amenities are available at the lodge?

The lodge features a full bar, a pool table, and event space suitable for private celebrations and group gatherings.

Can I host a private event or birthday party at the lodge?

Absolutely. The lodge has hosted birthday celebrations and other private events. Contact the lodge directly at 118 W Main St in Newcomerstown to discuss availability and arrangements.

Where exactly is the Newcomerstown Elks Lodge located?

The lodge is located at 118 W Main St, Newcomerstown, OH 43832, right on the main corridor through town.

How do I become a member of the Elks Lodge?

Membership in the BPOE is open to U.S. citizens who believe in God. Stop in and speak with one of the lodge officers, who are known for being approachable and happy to answer questions about joining.

What are the lodge's hours?

Hours can vary based on events and seasons. We recommend stopping by or checking with the lodge directly to confirm current operating hours before your visit.

69° Clear Newcomerstown
Mon 81° 65°
Tue 87° 59°
Wed 87° 69°
Thu 89° 68°
Fri 88° 67°
Sat 86° 66°
Sun 93° 65°
The Order · Since 1868

Community. Friendship. Charity.

Every Elks lodge belongs to one of America's oldest and largest fraternal orders. Through the Elks National Foundation, the Order has given more than $481 million to college scholarships, veterans, and neighbors in need.

Join the Elks
A Proud Heritage

The Elks gave America
Flag Day.

Long before it was a national observance, the Order set aside June 14th to honor the flag. Patriotism has always been one of our cardinal principles, and every lodge meeting still closes the same way it has for over a century.

“To our absent members.” — the Eleven O’Clock Toast

Get In Touch

Ready to get started? Contact us today!

Save to Contacts

More places nearby

Other spots near here, whatever their type. Tap one to open its page.

Discount Store ★ 4.0 (337)
Dollar General
0.4 mi101 W State St, Newcomerstown
Pizza Restaurant ★ 4.3 (200)
Damon's All American Pizza Pie
0.3 mi306 B, 306 S College St, Newcomerstown
American Restaurant ★ 4.5 (170)
Dick's Place
steps away102 N Bridge St, Newcomerstown
Pizza Delivery ★ 4.2 (213)
Domino's Pizza
0.2 mi224 E Canal St, Newcomerstown
Chinese Restaurant ★ 4.0 (284)
China Star
0.2 mi240 E Canal St, Newcomerstown
Hardware Store ★ 4.5 (37)
ORME HARDWARE EUREKA
0.2 mi102 N River St, Newcomerstown
Cafe ★ 4.6 (51)
Main Street Coffee
steps away143 W Main St, Newcomerstown
Sandwich Shop ★ 3.8 (176)
Subway
0.4 mi578 N College St, Newcomerstown

Contact Elks Lodge

Send a note and Elks Lodge will get back to you. No account needed.

Add an email or a phone so they can reply.

Best time to reach you
Community · Friendship · Charity

Who are the Elks?

The Benevolent and Protective Order of Elks is one of America's oldest and largest fraternal orders, founded in 1868. Every lodge is a home for fellowship, service, and patriotism in its own hometown.

$481M+given through the Elks National Foundation for scholarships, veterans, and community programs.

What the Order does

Report an issue

See something off? Tell us. We’ll fix it and improve the listing for everyone. No account required.